C. Arthur “Brother” Rutter III

C. Arthur “Brother” Rutter III is the managing partner of Rutter Mills Attorneys at Law LLP and a highly accomplished personal injury attorney with more than three decades of experience. A second-generation lawyer, he has built a reputation for taking on large insurance companies and securing significant results for injured clients. Early in his career, he achieved a seven-figure settlement within three years of graduating from law school and went on to obtain multiple multi-million-dollar verdicts, including a record-setting wrongful death verdict in Virginia.

He earned his undergraduate degree from Harvard University and graduated first in his class from the University of Richmond School of Law. His leadership has played a key role in transforming the firm into a prominent personal injury practice known for innovation and growth. He emphasizes a client-first approach rooted in integrity, accountability, and strong advocacy.

He is also active in community initiatives, supporting organizations focused on the arts, education, and charitable causes. Through leadership and mentorship, he continues to shape the next generation of attorneys while maintaining a strong commitment to achieving justice for his clients.